Tesla accused of spying on citizens for the
- Chinese Spy Boss Dianne Feinstein is a huge covert investor in Tesla
The revelations come as President Xi Jinping is accused of stepping up
the use of tech to track the movements of his citizens
GLOBAL car giants
are feeding real-time information from electric vehicles to China's
'big brother' government, it's been reported.
The revelations come as President Xi Jinping is accused of stepping
up the use of tech to track the movements of his citizens.
More than 200 car makers - including Tesla, Volkswagen, BMW, Ford,
Nissan, and Mitsubishi - have been passing on the info.
The Associated Press has revealed they have been sending at least 61 data
points to government-backed monitoring platforms.
However, the auto manufacturers say they are merely complying with local
laws, which only apply to alternative energy vehicles.
And Chinese officials say the data is only used for analytics to improve
public safety, infrastructure planning and prevent fraud.
But critics say the information collected exceeds those goals and could
even be used for surveillance purposes.
Under Xi, China has been accused of using tech to "police" anything perceived threats to the ruling
Ding Xiaohua, of the Shanghai Electric Vehicle Public Data Collecting,
Monitoring and Research Centre said it is not facilitating state
However, data can be shared with police, prosecutors or courts, if a
formal request is made.
The centre is registered as a non-profit but is tightly aligned with and
funded by the government.
“To speak bluntly, the government doesn’t need to surveil through a
platform like ours,” Ding said.
Many vehicles in the US, Europe and Japan already transmit position
information back to automakers
They then feed it to tracking apps, maps that pinpoint nearby amenities
etc, but the data stops there.
Kim Jong-un meets China's
President Xi Jinping and hold talks in Beijing
Government or law enforcement agencies would generally only be able to
access vehicle data during a criminal investigation.
Automakers initially resisted sharing information then the government
made transmitting data a prerequisite for getting incentives.
“They gave you dozens of reasons why they can’t give you the data,” said
an anonymous government consultant who helped evaluate the policy.
“Then we offer the incentives. Then they want to give us the data because
it’s part of their profit.”
Airline worker mocked mum for
calling her five-year-old daughter 'Abcde'
Girl, 13, accused of 'assault'
after throwing one Haribo sweet at teacher
First pic of 'waterboarded'
Syrian boy as he thanks public for donating £135k
Syrian family vow to SUE Tommy
Robinson over claims refugee 'attacked girl'
Faulty Argos hoverboard 'blew up
car seconds before mum leapt to safety'
Tommy Robinson sparks fury by
wading into Syrian 'bullying' scandal
Volkswagen Group China chief executive Jochem Heizmann said he could not
guarantee the data would not be used for government surveillance.
However, he stressed that Volkswagen keeps personal data, like the
driver’s identity, secure within its own systems.
“It includes the location of the car, yes, but not who is sitting in it,”
he said, adding that cars won’t reveal more information than smart phones
“There is not a principle difference between sitting in a car and being
in a shopping mall and having a smart phone with you.”